Katyn: I parenti delle vittime sono ancora all’oscuro sulla morte dei loro familiari

I parenti delle vittime di Katyn sono ancora all’oscuro sulla morte dei loro familiari.

I parenti delle vittime di Katyn sono ancora all’oscuro sulla morte dei loro familiari.

European Court: Katyń relatives remain in the dark about relatives’ deaths
At a public hearing today at the European Court of Human Rights, the final judgment in the case of Janowiec & Others v Russia was heard by relatives of the victims of the Katyń massacre (in which several thousands of Polish prisoners of war were killed by the Soviet secret police in 1940).
The relatives, who first lodged applications with the European Court in 2007 and 2009, claimed that the Russian authorities had failed to properly investigate the Katyń massacre, and that the Russian authorities’ ‘dismissive’ attitude to the investigation had amounted to inhuman or degrading treatment.
Although the Court called the facts of the execution of the applicants’ relatives ‘indisputable’ and did not question the “profound grief and distress that the applicants have experienced as a consequence of the extrajudicial execution of their family members”, it ruled that it had no competence to examine the effectiveness of the investigation. The Court noted that not only had the massacre happened before the European Convention on Human Rights had been adopted in 1950 but no significant investigative steps had taken place since Russia’s ratification of the Convention in 1998.
Russia, however, was found to have failed in its obligation to comply with the Court’s evidential requests. Specifically, the Court noted that the investigation’s key decision (to discontinue the investigation) remained classified, without the Russian Courts having conducted a substantive analysis of the reasons for maintaining that classification more than 70 years after the events in question.
The European Human Rights Advocacy Centre, which has been taking cases against Russia at the European Court for ten years, acted as a ‘third party intervener’ in this case together with Memorial and Essex Transitional Justice Network. They offered expertise on the obligation of states to investigate gross human rights violations and the right of relatives to know the truth about the circumstances of their relatives’ deaths or disappearance.
Joanna Evans, EHRAC Senior Lawyer, commented on the judgment:
“This decision will of course be hugely disappointing to the relatives of the victims of the Katyń massacre, who continue to hope for an effective investigation into the circumstances of their relatives’ deaths. However the Court’s reasoning in this case serves to highlight the significance of the rights protected by the European Convention since 1950 and the importance of its continued protection for victims of gross human rights violations in the present day.”
Notes
Following the Soviet invasion of Poland in 1939, thousands of Polish prisoners of war killed without trial on the order of the highest officials of the USSR and buried in mass graves in the Katyń forest near Smolensk.
The Soviet Union only accepted responsibility for Katyń in 1990, having initially blamed it on the Nazis. In 1990 a criminal investigation into the murders was opened but it was suspended in 2004 by the Russian Chief Military Prosecutor’s Office. The decision was classified.
In 2010 the Russian Duma published a statement, reiterating that the mass murder of Polish citizens had been carried out on Stalin’s orders and it was necessary to continue “verifying the lists of victims, restoring the good names of those who perished in Katyń and other places, and uncovering the circumstances of the tragedy…”.
The European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) has been working for the protection of human rights in the former Soviet Union since 2003 and has taken over 300 cases, mainly against Russia, to the European Court of Human Rights. This has led to judgments in 98 cases (so far) including the first six judgments ever to be secured against Russia for gross violations in Chechnya. 96% of these cases have found at least one violation of the European Convention on Human Rights, and more than €6,500,000 have been awarded to the applicants.

Aiutaci a crescere

Condividi su:

Per sostenere Memorial Italia

Leggi anche:

Domagnano (San Marino), 30 maggio 2025. Sopravvivere al Gulag. Una testimonianza al femminile.

Per lungo tempo non ci fu biancheria di ricambio. Ognuna di noi cercava di procurarsi qualcosa e di lavarlo, ma di norma avevamo soltanto la neve a disposizione. E per di più non c’erano detersivi di sorta, quindi si versava sulla cenere l’acqua ottenuta facendo fondere la neve e si lavava con quello. Ce ne andavamo in giro mal lavate, con gli abiti mal risciacquati e poco asciutti. Ai bagni ci davano poca acqua che – in mancanza di sapone – finiva soltanto con lo spalmare la sporcizia su tutto il corpo. In genere ne uscivamo a strisce, come le zebre. Venerdì 30 maggio alle 18:00 a Domagnano – San Marino (spazio espositivo Carlo Biagioli, via XXI marzo 71) si tiene l’incontro Sopravvivere al Gulag. Una testimonianza al femminile che prevede la presentazione del volume La mia vita nel Gulag. Memorie da Vorkuta 1945-1956 di Anna Szyszko-Grzywacz, ultima pubblicazione della collana Narrare la memoria, curata da Memorial Italia. Intervengono Aldo Calvani, Chiara Maria Consorti, Luca Bernardini, curatore del volume, e la nostra Barbara Grzywacz, figlia dell’autrice.

Leggi

Torino, 29 maggio 2025. Presentazione di “To the Success of Our Hopeless Cause” di Benjamin Nathans.

A Torino giovedì 29 maggio alle 16:30 presso la sala convegni della Fondazione Luigi Einaudi (via principe Amedeo 34) si tiene la presentazione del volume To the Success of Our Hopeless Cause. The Many Lives of the Soviet Dissident Movement (Princeton University Press 2024) di Benjamin Nathans. In collaborazione con il dipartimento di Studi storici dell’Università di Torino la Fondazione Luigi Einaudi in occasione del ciclo di incontri Il libro del giovedì ospita i nostri Simone Bellezza, Giulia De Florio e Alberto Masoero. L’incontro prevede la presentazione del volume To the Success of Our Hopeless Cause dello storico americano Benjamin Nathans, vincitore del premio Pulitzer 2025, dedicato alla storia del movimento della dissidenza sovietica. È possibile seguire l’incontro in presenza e on line sul canale YouTube della Fondazione Luigi Einaudi: Benvenuti sul canale della Fondazione Einaudi. Per maggiori informazioni: “To the success of our hopeless cause. The many lives of the Soviet dissident movement” di Benjamin Nathans | 29 maggio 2025, ore 16.30 – Fondazione Luigi Einaudi. Beginning in the 1960s, the Soviet Union was unexpectedly confronted by a dissident movement that captured the world’s imagination. Demanding that the Kremlin obey its own laws, an improbable band of Soviet citizens held unauthorized public gatherings, petitioned in support of arrested intellectuals, and circulated banned samizdat texts. Soviet authorities arrested dissidents, subjected them to bogus trials and vicious press campaigns, sentenced them to psychiatric hospitals and labor camps, sent them into exile – and transformed them into martyred heroes. Against all odds, the dissident movement undermined the Soviet system and hastened its collapse. Taking its title from a toast made at dissident gatherings, To the Success of Our Hopeless Cause is a definitive history of a remarkable group of people who helped change the twentieth century. Benjamin Nathans’s vivid narrative tells the dramatic story of the men and women who became dissidents – from Nobel laureates Andrei Sakharov and Alexander Solzhenitsyn to many others who are virtually unknown today. Drawing on diaries, memoirs, personal letters, interviews, and KGB interrogation records, To the Success of Our Hopeless Cause reveals how dissidents decided to use Soviet law to contain the power of the Soviet state. This strategy, as one of them put it, was “simple to the point of genius: in an unfree country, they began to conduct themselves like free people.” An extraordinary account of the Soviet dissident movement, To the Success of Our Hopeless Cause shows how dissidents spearheaded the struggle to break free of the USSR’s totalitarian past, a struggle that continues in Putin’s Russia – and that illuminates other struggles between hopelessness and perseverance today.

Leggi

28 maggio 2025. Incontro on line. Lettere ai prigionieri politici russi.

Memorial Italia invita a partecipare a un incontro on line nel corso del quale sarà possibile scrivere lettere e messaggi ai prigionieri politici russi. Si svolge sulla piattaforma Zoom mercoledì 28 maggio 2025 alle 19:00. Durante l’incontro non ci limiteremo a discutere i recenti casi politici che vedono coinvolti medici, scienziati, poeti, artisti, imprenditori, insegnanti, ma scriveremo insieme lettere e messaggi che sarà possibile inviare sia in formato digitale sia cartaceo. Per partecipare è necessario inviare una mail all’indirizzo projectpisma at gmail.com. Successivamente sarà inviato il link necessario per accedere a Zoom. Le lettere sono preziose: non solo aiutano i prigionieri ad affrontare la solitudine, ma rappresentano anche un importante strumento di difesa, dando dimostrazione dell’attenzione dell’opinione pubblica rispetto alla loro situazione. Ricordiamo che il progetto Поддержка политзеков (Sostegno ai prigionieri politici) di Memorial è presente on line in lingua russa –> memopzk.org/.

Leggi